INTRO TO NFTS
NFTs, or non-fungible tokens, have gained massive popularity in recent years, touching industries from fashion to video games. They are non-fungible, meaning each one is unique, and their status as a token indicates they stand in for something else – i.e. they’re linked to a specific benefit or good, but the token itself is just a certificate of that. When it comes to what an NFT can represent, it could be anything from a digital replica of Starry Night to a particularly well-worded tweet. On the flip side of non-fungible tokens, fungible tokens have also gained popularity in the form of cryptocurrencies. Each token, like Bitcoin, is exactly the same as the next token so is therefore fungible, but still a token. It is important to note that while both tokens are bought and sold on marketplaces like stocks are, their value is speculative. Their value is incredibly subjective, even more so than a stock which can represent a tangible stake in a company.
Both fungible and non-fungible tokens leverage blockchain technology, which in simplest terms is a series of ‘blocks’ that each contain information and are connected to each other. This chain of blocks (get it?) means the information contained in each block becomes an immutable record. To create an NFT, someone must ‘mint’ one, or publish the digital asset on the blockchain. NFTs can be bought and sold on a marketplace like a tangible good can, and the immutable record created by the blockchain provides proof of ownership for whoever has purchased the NFT. While ownership is solidified and proven with blockchain, another characteristic of blockchain technology is anonymity. We easily know who owns an NFT, but not the actual identity of that owner.
NFTS UNDER COPYRIGHT LAW
NFTs occupy a unique space under copyright law, but are subject to the basic rules other art forms are. The law protecting digital assets, the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), was passed in 1998 before NFTs were prevalent. The DMCA allows any artist to request a work be taken down if it something they have ownership over, and did not authorize the publication of. This extends to artists with any ownership stake, whether they are a singer-songwriter with sole ownership over a song, or a whole team of writers and producers.
Basic copyright laws also apply to NFTs; NFTs that are derivatives of other work are only allowable if the person who created the derivative work is a copyright owner of the original work, since a copyright owner automatically acquires rights to reproduce the work or create derivatives. So, for example, Harry Styles could mint an NFT of his song “Treat People With Kindness,” which would then be considered a derivative work even if it’s the exact same song available on Spotify, because now it’s a digital version of the song tokenized within the blockchain. Despite being a big Harry Styles fan, I could not legally mint this NFT because I do not own the copyright like Harry Styles does. To legally mint this song as an NFT, I’d need to make considerable changes to it to be allowable under the fair use doctrine of copyright law – like sample 10 seconds within an original work of mine. For NFTs that are copies or very close derivative works of an art work, the minter will need to follow basic copyright law to get permission from the copyright holder or license the work.
NFTS: AN EASY TARGET FOR COPYRIGHT INFRINGEMENT
We’ve established that NFTs are subject to basic copyright laws. However, they are much more challenging to monitor and regulate than other digital assets, and the NFT industry is hesitant to put stronger protections in place.
While the process for copyright owners to flag a violation and take their unauthorized work down is the same with NFTs as it would be otherwise thanks to DMCA, it’s the anonymity and lack of regulations that make it difficult. On marketplaces like OpenSea where someone mints, sells, and purchases NFTs, it’s easy to remain anonymous and there is little internal or external regulation. Additionally, the fact that the actual works are often not actually stored in the blockchain, just the representative tokens, makes it hard to take down the actual work and not just the listed NFT.
People are motivated to infringe copyright to mint NFTs because of its boom – demand for NFTs still outweighs supply. While popular marketplaces like OpenSea technically have policies against copyright infringement, enforcement is lax. On OpenSea and Rarible (another popular marketplace), there is no verification required to prove that something you’ve minted and/or listed is your own. Experts also point out that copyright is less relevant because of the speculative valuation of NFTs. As a token, there’s no intrinsic value to it, and that’s another reason why the industry is reluctant to put protections in place.
Additionally, minting NFTs is anonymous by default because of the blockchain. This makes the jurisdiction of where to take legal action murky, which makes taking action difficult despite laws outlining protection. Further, marketplaces make commission on sales, so there’s little motivating them to crack down on thousands of their hosted NFTs. Some marketplaces are working to create processes that better identify plagiarized content, but artists are still calling on them to do more.
NFTS & THE MUSIC INDUSTRY
NFTs have potential to benefit musicians. They offer a new revenue source, which is especially important when streaming platforms have significantly reduced the income artists get from their music. Artists can create hype with NFTs because of their rarity – each can be unique and quantity can be closely controlled. DJ Steve Aoki released NFTs while COVID-19 forced his usual concert revenue to slow. They can be a new form of memorabilia, something a fan can buy like they would a tour t-shirt at a concert to remember their experience.
However, in practice the music industry has fallen victim to the copyright issues NFTs present. Many musicians and other copyright owners are finding their work on NFT marketplaces, selling for vast amounts of money, without their permission.
Music piracy has always been an issue, especially as easily-accessible digital formats of music have become the norm. When LimeWire and Napster came onto the scene in the early aughts, they quickly rose in popularity. These websites made music sharing via digital files accessible to the masses who were burning CDs to share otherwise. This quickly led to a wave of pirated music being sent all over the internet. While Napster was acquired and set down the legal path and Limewire was sued out of existence, similar websites have always cropped up in their place. As new technological capabilities evolve, it is expected that the pursuit of piracy follows, which is exactly what is happening with NFTs – while not free to share music like their predecessors, NFT marketplaces are in a way the next generation of music piracy.
Earlier this year, HitPiece was created as a marketplace to sell songs as NFTs, just one of each recording. It touted exclusive access to the NFT version of fans’ favorite songs, and additional benefits like access to exclusive experiences with the artists behind the songs. However, it was not the artists or any owners of rights to the songs who were authorizing, creating, and selling these NFTs. There was a large public outcry from professionals in the music industry, in reaction to a company they’d never spoken to illegally profiting off their work. HitPiece was able to lift songs to mint them as NFTs via Spotify’s API, pointing to how easily anyone could do this.
HitPiece voluntarily shut down its operations after the negative reaction, including a scathing statement from the Recording Industry Association of America, but as of this article the company has not faced any legal trouble. The vulnerability of the music industry within NFT marketplaces remains.
LOOKING TO THE FUTURE: SOLUTIONS
Ultimately, better NFT copyright enforcement within the music industry will benefit artists/copyright owners, as well as NFT buyers who don’t want to buy counterfeit NFTs.
Some marketplaces and sites that are related to NFTs have listened to artists’ calls to do more about copyright infringement. Sites that promote artists, like DeviantArt, have set up blockchain alerts that flag when something listed as an NFT is found on their website. This could be replicated within the music industry, with a site like Spotify, for example.
Outside of marketplaces and music platforms, some third parties see an opportunity to step in. MarqVision is a 3rd party that monitors sites that partner with them for NFT theft.
There is also an opportunity for the government to step in. NFTs are amongst a variety of digital changes that the DMCA is not equipped to regulate after 24 years since it was signed into law. Although COVID-19 slowed momentum here, there have been updates proposed in Congress that we could see come into effect in the near future.
There is much work to do in this space to improve copyright protection in the NFT industry. While some of the aforementioned solutions may gain traction, not everyone is optimistic. One expert offers the opinion that the only solution to avoid copyright infringement is for artists to stop creating art, as scammers will ‘always be able to outsmart them.’ In any case, music industry professionals should understand the vulnerability of their work and consider monitoring NFT marketplaces to get ahead of being victims of copyright infringement. And, if someone out there is thinking about buying an NFT, make sure you are certain there’s no risk it is infringing copyright in any way.
References
Beckett, Lois. “‘Huge Mess of Theft and Fraud:’ Artists Sound Alarm as NFT Crime Proliferates.” The Guardian, January 29, 2022, sec. Technology. https://www.theguardian.com/global/2022/jan/29/huge-mess-of-theft-artists-sound-alarm-theft-nfts-proliferates.
De, Nikhilesh. “People Keep Tokenizing Other Users’ Art. Here’s How Artists Can Protect Their Work,” March 11, 2021. https://www.coindesk.com/tech/2021/03/11/people-keep-tokenizing-other-users-art-heres-how-artists-can-protect-their-work/.
JD Supra. “NFTs and Copyright Law.” Accessed April 18, 2022. https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/nfts-and-copyright-law-7361836/.
JD Supra. “Sweeping Changes Proposed to the DMCA’s Notice-and-Takedown System.” Accessed April 25, 2022. https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/sweeping-changes-proposed-to-the-dmca-s-2305255/.
Jr, Edward Ongweso. “Site Sells Famous Songs as NFTs Without Permission, Sparks Global Outrage.” Vice (blog), February 2, 2022. https://www.vice.com/en/article/pkpqyy/site-sells-famous-songs-as-nfts-without-permission-sparks-global-outrage.
McIntyre, Hugh. “The Piracy Sites That Nearly Destroyed The Music Industry: What Happened To Limewire.” Forbes. Accessed May 2, 2022. https://www.forbes.com/sites/hughmcintyre/2018/03/21/what-happened-to-the-piracy-sites-that-nearly-destroyed-the-music-industry-limewire/.
Marketplace. “How NFTs Could Change the Music Industry,” November 2, 2021. https://www.marketplace.org/2021/11/02/how-nfts-could-change-music-industry-better-worse/.
“MARQVISION | Protect Your Brands from Fakes.” Accessed April 18, 2022. https://www.marqvision.com/.
Middleton, Ryan. “RIAA Sends Letter Over ‘Copyright Theft’ To ‘Scam Site’ Music NFT Company HitPiece.” Magnetic Magazine. Accessed April 16, 2022. https://www.magneticmag.com/2022/02/riaa-sends-copyright-theft-letter-scam-site-music-nft-company-hitpiece/.
Munster, Ben. “People Are Stealing Art and Turning It Into NFTs.” Vice (blog), March 15, 2021. https://www.vice.com/en/article/n7vxe7/people-are-stealing-art-and-turning-it-into-nfts.
NFI. “What Is Minting an NFT? Everything You Need To Know,” April 13, 2022. https://www.nfi.edu/what-is-minting-an-nft/.
Rhett / Mankind. What Is an NFT? (Crypto Beginners), 2020. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a8ww4aNlPQU.
Stokel-Walker, Decrypt / Chris. “NFTs Have a Problem With Copyright Theft.” Decrypt, April 3, 2022. https://decrypt.co/96637/nfts-have-a-problem-with-copyright-theft.
Stephen, Bijan. “NFT Mania Is Here, and so Are the Scammers.” The Verge, March 20, 2021. https://www.theverge.com/2021/3/20/22334527/nft-scams-artists-opensea-rarible-marble-cards-fraud-art.
“The Digital Millennium Copyright Act | U.S. Copyright Office.” Accessed April 16, 2022. https://www.copyright.gov/dmca/.
The Young Turks. Website RIPS OFF Musicians By Selling Their Music As NFTs, 2022. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J8FgioSpENo.
Twitter. “Steve Aoki (@steveaoki) / Twitter.” Accessed April 25, 2022. https://twitter.com/steveaoki.
“U.S. Copyright Office Fair Use Index.” Accessed April 23, 2022. https://www.copyright.gov/fair-use/.
“What Musicians Should Know about Copyright | U.S. Copyright Office.” Accessed April 18, 2022. https://www.copyright.gov/engage/musicians/.
“World’s Largest Online Art Gallery Deviantart Collaborates With Opensea to Detect Potential NFT Infringement – Blockchain Bitcoin News.” Accessed April 23, 2022. https://news.bitcoin.com/worlds-largest-online-art-gallery-deviantart-collaborates-with-opensea-to-detect-potential-nft-infringement/.