Response to Marianne on Olafur Eliasson’s ‘Water Pendulum’

Olafur Eliasson is one of the big names when talking about how materiality can be produced and perceived in unconventional ways. In contrast with other projects where he focuses on the use of light and visual effects to mislead our vision, this one explores the nature of time by diminishing our seen reality. It comes to my mind another artist that has also explored time in his pieces, again with strobe lights, to obtain that low-framerate effect.

‘kinematope [gare d’austerlitz]’ (2014) and ‘kinematope [croisement]’ (2018) are some of the immersive light installations created by the Spanish artist Pablo Valbuena that explore the manipulation of time to transform an architectural space. In these installations, a set of spotlights ignite keeping up with a fluctuant rhythm that speeds up in time. The dark space becomes timeless, and the visitor loses his conscience of movement. The shadows freeze and space turns into an expanded zoetrope.

Original post:

Other projects reviewed: Christian Marclay’s ‘The Clock’, Dirk Koy’s ‘Escape Route’, Richard McGuire’s ‘HERE’, Charles Lohr’s ‘Non-Euclidian Renderer’.

 

Project To Share: Add On – Experiments with Security Camera

Art and Surveillance Project

The Art Surveillance Project has an ongoing online database that “catalogues artists, artworks, and exhibitions addressing surveillance within Canada post-9/11.” Founded by Dr. Susan Cahill at the University of Calgary, the directory was a response to the “War on Terror” in 2001. The artworks on the site range from glass engravings to huge googly eyes to mirrored domes.

Original Post:

Other Reviewed Articles:

 

Project Response

This is a response to Steven’s post about Marmalade Type:

I know that the primary interest of this piece seems to be its optical illusion, but it got me thinking about how one could merge ExCap with typography. I am 90% sure that in a past class with Golan I saw someone make a project using Kinect where the shape of one’s body controlled various details of a font, so they could dance around and create their own personal typeface. I looked for it a while and couldn’t find it, so instead I offer you a link to this website about manually manipulating fonts (still pretty fun): https://v-fonts.com/

Also read: Joyce’s post on “Delusional Crime and Punshiment”, Philippe’s post on “The Clock”, Izzy’s post on “Learning to See”, and Stacy’s post on “Tea Ceremony”.

Response: Marianne, Eliasson’s Water Pendulum

Marianne’s post introduced Eliasson’s water pendulum, a water stream illuminated by strobe light to highlight the unpredictable flow of water. This reminded me of Daniel Wurtzel’s work which shows the chaotic nature of air currents and how it can be made visible through various materials. however, rather than focusing on the erratic movements of the air currents Wurtzel has tried to highlight the fluidity and beauty of this unstable movement by often incorporating dancers or other performers to interact with the materials trapped in his invisible vortex.

Air Fountain | Daniel Wurtzel

artist website: http://www.danielwurtzel.com/index.cfm 

(also reviewed: David, Steven, Joyce, and Oscar)

 

Project to Share Review : Marianne

   I wanted to expand upon Marianne’s “Project to Share” entry on Olafur Eliasson’s Water Pendulum. I agree that this work is phenomenal. After the photogrammetry workshop yesterday with Claire Hentschker, my mind kept going to the lightning bolt she showed us that was captured at two different angles and made into an object. This got me wondering if the stills from this video could be used to make a 3D capture. I’m not sure if this would be possible using the photogrammetry methods we learned in class on 1/21 because the water is in motion, but it’s an interesting thought to ponder.

Other projects reviewed;

Steven

Lumi

Joyce

Oscar

Joseph

 

 

Response to Sean

I resonate with the point that Sean made in his review of the BriefCam, that the re-purposing of surveillance technologies can lead to creative opportunities. Surveillance footage plus analytic functionalities allow for the manipulation of visual information across space and time. BriefCam superimposes different moments of the same place together, which is ‘eerie,’ as Sean calls it, and I quite feel it. I also want to add that surveillance camera gives a sense of power, because in a way, BriefCam offers a type of ‘god-view.’ Demonstrated even in the graphic novel HER, which Sean mentions, the ability to collapse images over the course of thousands of years empowers the user/reader/audience to experience history with a new perspective.

This reminds me of Dragonfly Eyes, a feature-length narrative film by Xu Bing. It is made entirely from surveillance footage in China. Seemingly disconnected, random, transient slices of life in the form of security footage are pieced together by the artist to tell one cohesive story. Unlike works of surveillance art that emphasize the critique of and resistance towards oppressive use of the technology (as in Joseph’s post), this feature film does not quite strike me as a critique. As the film creates narrative with surveillance footage, it also creates a type of romance. Instead of acknowledging that China is a surveillance state,  the film seems to (try to) prove that there is something poetic about it (and that the person who understands such poetry is the one who can collect, access, and own these surveillance footage). I wonder what the artist felt like when he was editing this film, and if he felt like a god.

Other posts reviewed:

Project To Share Response

Reviewed Posts By:

  • Izzy
  • Christian
  • Olivia
  • Steven
  • Philippe

In response to Izzy’s shared project, the concept of GANs/Style Transfer has been popping up a lot in the world of Art. https://www.thispersondoesnotexist.com is a popular example of where we are currently with our generative abilities, and large companies such as Nvidia are always pushing out new algorithms that get us farther from the uncanny valley to a point where we can’t even tell reals from fakes. Machine Learning is based on the idea that with enough data, you can approximate any function to such a precise degree that not even us humans can tell the difference. With such a large database of images on Google, people can easily scrape larger and larger datasets to train on. Not only are our models growing more accurate, but our datasets are always getting larger.

Gloomy Sunday was posted 2 years ago, and we’ve made such large progress in machine learning over this time. I wonder what type of results we would get now if we were to retrain the model on the must updated Pix2Pix algorithm with a larger dataset (could we make it so convincing that humans would think it’s real?)

‘Triple Chaser’ by Forensic Architecture | Addon

What does it look like to wield machine learning algorithms for good? In “Triple Chase,” the act of building an image recognition system serves here as a way to level power differentials between innocent victims, activists and global arms traders. In this case, the knowledge of where a company is distributing weapons can be wielded against that company’s reputation for justice.

What’s fascinating about Forensic Architecture at large is the use of footage to reconstruct the layers of events that have been lost. Indeed, the leveling power in Forensic Architecture’s approach is this notion of revealing unseen, or intentionally suppressed, relationships. In this sense, I ask what power dynamics reside in the ability to know, uncover, or suppress these relationships?

Speaking of power, the democratization of machine learning processes in libraries like Ml5.js (among others) serves as a way to open up the privilege of new ways of knowing about the world. In what ways can we, as educated technologists, further open up the power of computer vision to artists, activists, and non-technologists?

Original post:

Other articles reviewed:

 

Olafur Eliasson, Water Pendulum (2010)

Olafur Eliasson (1967) creates space-filling installations by a collaborative interdisciplinary team of artists, media specialist, scientist and architects. Eliasson’s main concerns are the changing nature of time, light, air temperature and space to find alternate ways to sense and engage with the environment, especially in these difficult times of climate crisis.

Water Pendulum (2010) is an installation that presents dancing water streams illuminated by strobe light that transforms the unpredictable flow of water into frozen moments. Inspired by Eadweard Muybridge’s studies of motion in animals, this work turns the photographic act into a spatial phenomenon to speculate around the relative nature of time.

‘Triple Chaser’ by Forensic Architecture

‘Triple Chaser’ by Forensic Architecture

Forensic Architecture's 'Triple Chaser,' model being trained

In 2018 the US fired tear gas canisters at civilians at the USA/Mexico Border and images identifying these munitions as ‘triple chaser’ tear gas grenades emerged. These are produced by the Safariland Group,which is owned by Warren B. Kanders who is the vice chair of the board of trustees of the Whitney Museum of American Art. Why mention all of this?

During the 2019 Whitney Biennial Exhibition, Forensic Architecture decided to create a camera that employed machine learning and computer vision techniques to scour the internet and determine in what conflicts (often states oppressing people) these tear gas canisters were being used. This information is not something easy to find and there were even not enough images of the canisters available to create an effective computer vision classifier, so they had to create models and make their own data so the classifier could work and then be used to identify real-world examples of where the were being used. The results and process of this investigation were then shown at the exhibition. They eventually withdrew the work from the exhibition in response to inaction on their findings.

What I love about this work is the use of inventive technology to create a solution for justice-oriented journalism/activism that would be impossible without the invention of the tools it crested. There would be no other way to sift through endless footage to put together a damning case of the widespread use of these tear gas devices and their relationship to a board member of the Whitney without the use of creating a process, or a performance, that can operate on its own. Also the idea of creating data needed to mine real world data in an effective way seems to be an interesting process for thinking about capture and how to deal with intentionally created blind spots. How to teach something to see as an act of art and activism?

Link to the video they created and presented is here.

Link to their methodology and explanation for creating the object identifier here.